Logo

Valentines Day Ecards

NY POST ASKS – IS TWILIGHT WORTH READING?

Posted October 7th, 2008 By: 12 Comments »

New York Post’s Pop Wrap asks “Is Twilight Worth Reading?” Jarett Wieselman, the author of the article, intends to see the movie but he’s not sure if he should read the books first. Here are his pros and cons:

 
So here’s my question: should I read the books before seeing the movie? Waiting is not an option because once I watch the film my desire to know more will evaporate – it’s something that must be decided before I plunk down $10.

In the pro column – the series is clearly very compelling and well-written despite a supposedly disappointing final installment. Obviously everything in the books can not be included so I’d have a fully fleshed out sense of the universe when the movie unspools if I were to sit down with the tomes beforehand.

In the con column – it’s a lot to tackle. There are 2,592 pages of fanged fiction in the four installments of the “Twilight” saga and knowing that the last book, “Breaking Dawn,” was a major letdown for fans doesn’t exactly make me want to renew my library card.

So tell me, what should I do?

SOURCE

I think he should read at least Twilight before seeing the movie. Maybe he won’t find the series daunting if he starts out with one and then decides if he wants to read the rest. I believe he can appreciate the movie more knowing the back story, especially considering a lot of the book couldn’t be fit into the movie. He will get descriptive detail about the characters and storyline. What do you think? To read or not to read?







Read More About:
Filed under: News Blog, Twilight TA Toolbar: Download Here
advertisement
  • http://www.twilightersanonymous.com Paula Jeanne Colwell

    Of course he should read it before he sees the movie. And not EVERYONE was disappointed in Breaking Dawn. I love the entire series…you can’t have the series without all of the books. I have never seen a movie that was completely by the book but we have been told that they really tried to be true to the book. Lets hope right? 44 days and counting!!

  • Ana

    I think he should definitely read Twilight. I agree with Paula, not EVERYBODY hated Breaking Dawn, I LOVED IT!!! A lot of people that I talk to liked it too, so I don’t know what’s wrong with some people, frankly. If he decides to continue reading (which let’s face it, with a cliff hanger like Twilight’s, who wouldn’t want to continue??)I’m sure he will. I always like to be MY OWN critic, so I did not pay ATTENTION to anyone’s critisicm when it came to Breaking Dawn, and I’m so happy I didn’t because I loved it!! It’s everything we’ve been waiting for, Edward and Bella get married, Bella becomes a vampire, and they’re some twists to it too, what’s not to love? But anyways back to this guy, I say he should read it, and let him be his own critic.

  • aLIcE CuLLeN

    okay, that is the single most IDIOTIC question I have ever HEARD! no $#!t he should read the book before seeing the movie! the books are absolutely AMAZING and have yet to meet their equal in a novel. (yes, i do love harry potter, but vampires come before wizards. sorry.) READ THE BOOKS! READ THE BOOKS! READ THE BOOKS! READ THE BOOKS! READ THE BOOKS! READ THE BOOKS! READ THE BOOKS! READ THE BOOKS! READ THE BOOKS! READ THE BOOKS! READ THE BOOKS! READ THE BOOKS! READ THE BOOKS! READ THE BOOKS! READ THE BOOKS! READ THE GOSH DANGIT FREAKING AMAZING BOOKS!
    thank you!

  • Paulette

    Of course you should read it. The entire series is great including Breaking Dawn. I wasn’t disappointed. Although I tend to favor Jacob, it all worked out in the end. I actually really liked New Moon. I liked how it built the relationship between Jacob and Bella, but also showed how in love Bella was with Edward. You just gotta read all four books! It’s well worth it.

  • Nikki

    I think he should definitely read all 4 books. The majority of readers loved Breaking Dawn and most of those who didn’t wanted more sex and blood. NEWS FLASH…NOT EVERYBODY IS MORALLY BANKRUPT!
    If he decides not to read the books, he’ll only be missing out.

  • Chancy Rose

    Why should he read the book? If they did as good a job on the movie as everyone is expecting, then the movie should do the book justice AND leave a first time visitor to the Twilight universe wanting more. Remember, folks, they’re not trying to appeal to only Twilight fans, they’re actually trying to lure people in who don’t know anything (or very little) about SM’s universe. So no, don’t read the book(s)…see what Catherine gives you. So many people seem to have such great faith in her and Melissa Rosenberg, so keep the faith.

    After all, look at how many Harry Potter fans there are who have never touched the books and love the Potter-verse based only on the movies. This is not a comparison, mind you, but only an observation: not everyone has to read the book to like/love the movie.

  • Emily=]

    Urgh it realy annoys me when people say breaking dawn was a disappointment! It wasnt! It was the way Stephenie wanted the series to end so get over it if you didnt like the ending! He would be totally missing out if he doesnt read the books first-the movie is never as good as the book and in this case its imposible-saying that the movie is gonna be awesome to.

  • Laura ( OBSESSED )

    BREAKING DAWN WASNT DISAPPOINTING AT ALL!! people were just upset cuz the series ended when it could have continued on for so much longer!
    the books are INCREDIBLE. they are my life now. they are incredibly addicting and i have gotten so many people into the books and they all love it. READ THEM!!! i have read them all about 4 times now and they never get dull

  • Alyce

    (yes thats my real name) THANK YOU! finally ive found people who loved breaking dawn as much as i do! i think it was a perfect ending. and it pisses me off that this guy is only paying atention to the fact that abunchof losers hated BD. nikki ure so right!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • VanessaC

    I just had to say, Im SO glad to finally find other ppl willing to say how much they loved BD! I LOVED it myself, and I was completely dumbfounded when I got on the internet after reading it and read about all the hate… I honestly just couldn’t understand it, and still don’t. It’s tied (w/Eclipse) for my fav book of the series, I thought it was an AWESOME ending, and I just really don’t see how Stephenie could have done any better… oh well, I understand that everyone’s entitled to their own opinion, and that’s fine, but that doesn’t mean I UNDERSTAND that opinion… and in this case, I definitely don’t understand why ppl hated BD so much… I thought it was GREAT! So glad to find there are others who agree w/me :)

  • liz

    Absolutely read the books!
    the movie was ordinary at best. over acted, edward seemed controlling and awkward(although very handsome), and they left out some of my favourite moments.
    the books were some of the best and most descriptive writing i’ve ever read! very moving. I was completely sucked into the world of twilight. and i really enjoyed that world. untill the real world went crazy with it and stared acting like controlling and obsessing movie edward.

  • Amanda Isabella James

    Read the fricken books! THEY ARE REALLY GOOD!!! I mean I didnt even want to read the books but as soon as I picked up Twilight I was HOOKED!! You should really read the book before the movie because the book is usually always better than the movie. The movie sometimes leaves stuff out EX. Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, Its the longest dang book in the entire series yet the movie is REALLY short! and sometimes you cant understand stuff because its explained better in the book so yes read the books and like ‘um. Trust me you will because the Twilight Saga has appealed to the most picky of readers… (me…)

 

 

 
More in News Blog, Twilight (7043 of 7453 articles)