Logo

Valentines Day Ecards

REELZ CHANNEL FACEOFF: CEDRIC DIGGORY VS. EDWARD CULLEN

Posted December 5th, 2008 By: Team Switzerland 19 Comments »

We constantly hear comparisons between Twilight and Harry Potter, especially since Robert Pattinson happened to star in both. So now ReelzChannel has created their own faceoff between Robert’s character in Harry Potter, Cedric Diggory, and his character in Twilight, Edward Cullen. So who wins? See for yourself:

 
In Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, Robert Pattinson plays Cedric Diggory, a 17-year-old Hogwarts student. In Twilight, he plays Edward Cullen, a perpetually 17-year-old student now enrolled at Forks High School. Both characters consistently prove their bravery, loyalty, and desire to do right.

Not much difference so far, right? But we got to thinking…Cedric is a wizard. Edward is a vampire. If the two squared off, who would win? See our judges’ results below.

(If you are unable to read the text, click here)

(Thanks Hugz)

Okay, so Reelz Channel has declared Cedric the winner – I’m not so sure I can argue with that. Their reasoning is pretty true and hey, Cedric has a wand. I still think Edward would give him a run for his money…

What do you think about this faceoff? Do you agree with Reelz Channel’s decision?







Read More About:
Filed under: News Blog TA Toolbar: Download Here
advertisement
  • Taylor

    Rob as Cedric Diggory pwns Rob as Edward Cullen, but as characters in the books Edward wins in my mind. I don’t agree with them if they were talking about the book characters and not the characters in the movie. Oh, DARN IT! I don’t think I’m making sense anymore!

  • Susan

    There’s no category for “romantic appeal” – if there were, Edward would win hands-down!

  • Satu

    If it comes to a fight Edward wins because Cedric’s spells would just bounce off his diamond hard skin. Besides, Edward is so fast Cedric wouldn’t even have a chance.

    As a characters in a book, I’ve always prefered Edward. I just have a thing in mysterious loners :)

  • Veronica

    Oh yeah! Cedric so rules!! The Goblet of Fire is my ultimate favorite movie. Sorry Twilighters, Cedric’s just awesome.

  • MsMoon

    Too funny…very clever. I knew when I saw him as Cedric that kid was going places. He had an excellent screen presence even then.

  • Sally

    WHAT!!! Edward so has more hair-touching appeal than cedric

  • Mrs.Cullen

    How can it be a draw in fighting skills? Cedric died intantly and Edward won?! I’m sooo confused on how it is a draw. Edward wins hands down. And everyone likes hair that’s all messed :) TEAM EDWARD! + Cedric only bet Harry Potter because of the interference of the Dementors not because of skill! Robert Pattinson has sex appeal!!!!

  • edward=love

    edward SHOULD have won.. :(

  • iAmy

    Edward should have totally won. Cedic is okay, but he is nowhere near better thab Edward. He really should have won the hair-touching appeal!

  • Kristin

    I think Edward should have won the school success category; he’s a Harvard and Dartmouth graduate. I also think his scowling ability surpasses Cedric’s, and his fighting skills are FAR better.

  • Larissa

    I think it would be Edward. I love Cedric, he’s one of my favorite characters in Harry Potter, but Edward, is just way amazing. School wise, he had a ton of degrees and knew a lot of things. Anyways, I just think he’d win. And they forget about Edward’s fight in Eclipse.

  • Pattisons a twat

    I was a great fan of twilight until they done the film and pattison completely ruined Edward. He is Cedric digory, always has been, always will be. With his fake american accent and stupid hair he just ruins twilight. They could at least get someone half decent to play Edward.

  • tara

    As the characters in the book go, since edward is a main character in all four twilight books n cedric is in only like 2 harry potter books n not a main character seen all throughout the harry potter books. edward wins. plus i personally liked edwards character in twilight better than cedric diggory. rob looks adorable playing both so either way i guess for this, but wen it comes to edward vs. cedric, edward wins hands down.

  • credric wins

    Definitely Cedric! Rob looks much better in that movie, in comparison to Twilight. The whole ‘white skin and statuesque features’ thing just doesnt work for Rob… Cedric is way braver if you think about it too…completing all those tasks, and then protecting Harry at the end.. sorry but Edward just doesnt make the cut.

  • http://twilightersanonymous.com/reelz-channel-faceoff-cedric-diggory-vs-edward-cullen.html sadd

    thank u ur so right :)

  • alyssa

    Edward should have won for fighting ability cuz he actually won the fight. Emmett and Jasper may have killed James, but Edward had him beat before they showed up. as for hair touching, it should be a draw, just because its Rob and i wanna touch his hair no matter what character he is. and i love both characters, so i’m happy either way. but anyway, since they’re the same person they should have each other’s backs, not fighting each other

  • Abby

    YES! Finally someone who agrees with me! Honestly, Edward kind of disgusts me in the movies… and I see him as a terrible boyfriend so…

  • vampirella

    askımm senin için canmı veririm ama sende bana bi kıyak yapp türkiyeye gel (adana)lütfen I love you edward Ilike edward I enjoy edward I’m crayz edward(rob) :)

  • http://twitter.com/BrielleAriana Brielle Lassiter

    Either way, each character is played by Rob, and he's Hot!!.. soo… both are winners to me..

 

 

 
More in News Blog (6379 of 7413 articles)