Logo

Valentines Day Ecards

TA TALKS BACK: MR. DARCY VERSUS EDWARD CULLEN

Posted February 2nd, 2009 By: 30 Comments »

TA Forum member JW Healy has prepared an awesome comparison of Mr. Darcy (Pride and Prejudice) and Edward Cullen (Twilight)

 

Which Movie Boyfriend Would You Rather Have?

With Valentine’s Day fast approaching, thoughts turn to boy friends and how much we love them. So, who are the sexiest, sweetest, most desired cinema boy friends, you wonder? I can think of two: Mr. Darcy from Pride and Prejudice and Edward Cullen from Twilight. How do they stack up as boy friends? How do they compare to each other? Take this quiz and find out which one would be better for you.
 

Does your heart not yearn for Mr. Darcy or Edward? Then, which cinema boy friend do you desire?

To see larger image, click here

What do you think? Who would be your choice? Talk Back to us….







Read More About:
Filed under: TA Talks Back TA Toolbar: Download Here
advertisement
  • http://themidnighters.ology.com/ Olga

    Before I read the books and saw the Twilight movie my favorite literary character was Mr. Darcy. Now it is sort of hard for me to pick between Edward Cullen and Mr. Darcy but I would absoulutely pick Edward!

  • chicgeek

    Wow, that’s a tough one! But since this is make-believe, I will pick the ultimate make-believe character…Edward Cullen!
    (Still, I love, love, love Mr. Darcy!)

  • http://www.twilightnewborns.com Melissa

    What a great comparison that I never thought of before. You could even add that both Edward and Mr. Darcy speak similarly. I would pick Edward because he has more world knowledge from having lived longer. And I love peacoats more than top hats anyday.

  • Jane

    Can I just call Rob Mr. Darcy? Is that allowed????

  • Ana

    Yea, Mr Darcy DID have some sort of a mystery to him–but it’s Edward who captured me instead.

    AND he loves to dance…AND he can play the piano…AND he’s just more beautiful and will remain that way forever with a beautiful soul–can’t resist that.

  • Lynn

    I agree with Olga at first Mr. Dacy was my fav but then Edward came along and it was like love at 1st sight!!! Edward all the way!!!!
    I’m sorry Mr. Darcy
    Edward is just so sexy and dreamy!!!!

  • EdwardsBrand

    This is so unfiar…how can you choose?! I might have to say Mr. Darcy! I LOVE the line “You’ve bewitched me, body and soul and I love, love…love you!” *swoons

  • Angela

    Can we wait until Rob is 28 and then do another P&P remake?! :D

    But then, he might prefer playing Mr. Wickham. Gah!

    I think I would choose Edward, but he’s not so aloof.

  • Nikki

    I mean, Mr Darcy’s hot nd all but there’s no excitement of the supernatural world there that Bella goes through, so I’d have to say Edward Cullen, so adventurous!

  • Kayla

    Okay, for me, this is like no comparison. Edward all the way! lol
    I DEFINITELY would choose Edward over Darcy any day! No offense to Darcy or fans of him…

  • Jenniffer

    Well, i would choose Edward hands down becuase i mean who would not want a vampire for a boyfriend.

  • http://www.amybesse98.blogspot.com amy

    Well before the Twilight Saga for sure Mr. Darcy.. But I would have to say Edward Cullen… But then again I like both of them they don’t fall for the typical pretty girl who walks around with her nose stuck in the air.. Both Girls they fall for which I also fall in the same category is unique, beautiful, independent and strong willed…

  • kelly E

    Decisions decisions! haha I took the quiz and guess what – they were both equal! lol I take option C – BOTH!

  • teamjacob1

    According to the list, Mr. Darcy. And I pretty much agree with that. Edward is great and fantatic and all BUT he has major overprotective issues. Bella shouldn’t have had to sneak out to see her best friend. ANd there’s also the constant “I’m a monster.” thing. Over and over, he repeats that. True, Mr. Darcy’s pride is his ultimate downfall and it makes him appear haughty and rude, but he’s still a gentleman.
    WHat’s really funny is tht in my last fanfic chapter, they were watching “Pride and Prejudice” and Bella was comparing the two, saying that Mr. Darcy could never match up.

  • jennie

    omfg that is so hard

    can i just say both???

    but if u meen ppl r gonna force me to choose
    ………………………………………………………………………
    Edward

  • mel_b2980

    Yeah…no matter what…Edward still wins hands down…lol.

  • summerofjoy

    I’ll choose Edward Cullen all the way! I like my men a bit more modern than Mr. Darcy ;) Besides there’s something to be said about a hot vampire ready to make himself absolutly miserable if that would make you feel just a wee bit better ^^

  • bec

    EDWARD ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! lol

  • love him

    EDWARD can´t be compared he´s absolutely the best!!!!!!!

  • K_Cullen

    You all can have Edward and Mr. Darcy. I want Robert Pattinson!!

  • http://twlightchracters.com amber

    I pick edward cullen because he is hotter than that other guy from pride and prejudice. edward is the one Ichoose because he was awsome playing in the movie twilght.

  • Alysha

    Edward Of Course! I Mean its Edward Come On!

  • Jill Cullen

    I would pick Edward Cullen because he has seen & experienced more things than Mr. Darcy. I still love Mr. Darcy though! :)

  • Echo

    i like em both, but i would have to say edward……
    however, my own allegiance lies with SETH!
    who’s with me??????

  • Shavon

    Considering that she has said in interviews that she loosely based Twilight on Pride & Prejudice, and that Edward has elements of Mr. Darcy, I find this hard to choose. Plus, I’m kind of an Emmett girl myself.

  • http://wohow.co.nr Arwa

    ONLY MR DARCY! Edward cannot be compared to the legendary creation of Jane Austen.
    but I rather prefer Colin Firth over Matthew Macfadyen.

  • http://yahoomail jessica

    hi you are the best person i have ever meet i love the movie you made you are awesome!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Jasmine

    MR DAECY, ALWAYS. <3
    I don't know a thing about Twilight, nor do I care a thing about it, but I LOVE Pride and Prejudice, and was wondering how the amazing Mr. Darcy could be compared with Edward Cullen…. I see there is no comparison. Hehe….Mr. Darcy is infinitely better according to this quiz. Although this should have been done according to the 1995 BBC COLIN FIRTH VERSION, which is as much more amazing as I believe the 2005 version is compared to Twilight. Then again, I don't know much about Twilight…ah well.. I just know I looove my Mr. Darcy<3 <3

  • villy

    What kind of question is that?Mr Darcy by faaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaar!!!!Who wants a sparkly vampire?

  • villy

    What kind of question is that?Mr Darcy by faaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaar!!!!Who wants a sparkly vampire?

 

 

back to Top
 
More in TA Talks Back (159 of 182 articles)