‘The Twilight Saga: Eclipse’ Movie Review By Kara
The Twilight Saga: Eclipse officially hits theaters tomorrow and I expect a whole wave of new Twilight fans will be revealing themselves soon. From the acting and the effects to the dialogue and the music, Eclipse is in a different league not only than its predecessor, but than many films this year. Whether Eclipse is your favorite (or even least favorite) book in the saga, I predict even the purest of fans will be nothing less than thrilled with the film adaptation. Being a devoted Twihard myself, I’ve broken down the film into different sections that I feel sums up the movie best. So read on for my full review, but be careful because there are spoilers if you have yet to see it!
As a whole, I would say the acting in the film is really, really great. Robert, Taylor, and Kristen delivered their lines wonderfully and at no point did they ever feel forced. Their lines always felt real and genuine and the trio were a joy to watch on screen.
The wolf pack and the humans didn’t get too much room to show off, but the short bits they were in were truly memorable. Jessica’s graduation speech? Flawless.
The Volturi wasn’t in the forefront all that much either, but the few scenes and lines of dialogue they had were really spot on. Dakota (as Jane) kept up with her evil yet sweet facade, while Dan Cudmore, Charlie Bewley, and Cameron Bright each had their moment to shine a bit too.
The bad vamps were some serious awesome in this film. Xavier Samuel absolutely shined in Eclipse and really knocked my socks off. I see big things for him in the future and I am so thoroughly impressed with his talent. Bryce as Victoria: Not crazy about her hair wig, but I thought Bryce’s acting was spot on. I wholly expect to hear complaints about Bryce because the continuity of the acting wasn’t seamless from Rachelle to her, but I think they each brought their own touch to the role. Rachelle made us fear Victoria and made her a very strong, independent character. Bryce brought book-Victoria to life with her timidity and soft, childlike voice (and remember – Bella does say that she’s surprised by Victoria’s childlike voice in the book). So all in all, Bryce brought as much as she could to the role and succeeded (in my eyes, at least). Do I miss Rachelle? Always, but I will forever embrace Bryce.
Loved the music in the film. Though I would have liked to have seen heard the use of some of my favorite songs in the film (Florence + the Machine’s Heavy In Your Arms, for one), the ones who actually did make it into the film were expertly placed. Sia’s My Love tugged at your heart strings, while The Black Keys’ Chop and Change kicked the film off on a perfect note. Honorable mention? Neutron Star Collision (Love is Forever) by Muse. I was pleasantly surprised to hear the song placed in the film rather than in the credits like the title tracks for both Twilight and New Moon. If you read my review from the soundtrack, UNKLE’s With You In My Head was one of the songs I just didn’t like. After hearing its placement in the film, it’s now one of my favorites on the soundtrack. What Supermassive Black Hole is to Twilight’s baseball scene, With You In My Head is to Eclipse’s fight training scene.
I said it last year and I’ll say it again…I am not a CGI savvy gal. I was hugely impressed with Chris Weitz’s CGI skills in New Moon, but I was dumbfounded at David Slade’s use of effects in Eclipse. A favorite for me was the scene when Bella interacts with Jacob in his wolf form. The realistic effects let you focus on the trueness and the purity of the scene.
• Key Scenes: Before each film, we all make our own mental (and in some cases, physical) lists of what scenes should be taken directly from the book. I can safely say that Eclipse included a good 90% of my list.
- Fight Training: The music fit perfectly, we get to see more Cullen interaction, and it’s a fun scene whether you’re a Twilight fan or not.- The Actual Battle: One word to sum up this scene? Wow. Literally, just wow. I’m just as shocked as David Slade is that the MPAA approved some of the decapitations and limb severing that they did, but boy, am I glad they did. At no point is the battle ever gruesome or “too much”, but it’s always just right. This will be a standout scene for Twihard and non-Twihards alike.
- Tent Scene: “Well, I am hotter than you.” Need I say more? No, but I will: Hilarious dialogue, doesn’t ever seem rushed, and will definitely be a favorite among fans.
- Other Notables: Jasper’s backstory, Rosalie’s flashback, the story of “The Third Wifeâ€, Bella punching Jacob, the proposal, leg hitch, and several others.
- Angela and Bella Addressing Graduation Invites: I feel guilty even putting this scene down since we know it was shot and will even end up on the DVD, but it’s just one of those things that I would have liked to have seen in the film (after all, we don’t get much human interaction!).- Others I noticed: Alice ‘kidnapping’ Bella, Bella flash forwarding to her life if she chose to pick Jacob (which was actually in the initial script), and a few others that it didn’t kill me to see excluded.
• Direct Quotes: I am impressed at the amount of quotes taken from the book and added into the film, but in the same sense there are a few quotes that seriously hit me where it hurts when I didn’t hear them in the film. One I will give a ‘pass’, because technically based on the story timeline it could still be in Breaking Dawn and that’s my all-time favorite, “Look after my heart, I’ve left it with you…†One I just can’t come to terms with the lack of? “For the first time in almost a century, I felt hope.†Ouch, just..ouch.
The plus side? The ones they did include (and possibly slightly paraphrased), worked perfectly. “No Emmett, I punched a werewolf in the face†and just about the entire proposal scene, among others. Oh, and don’t be surprised that I need to give a shout out to the “From now on, I’m Switzerland!” declaration by Bella. (Hollaaa!)
Yes, the romance deserves a category of its own. From the initial meadow scene to the leg hitch scene, the proposal to the Edward/Bella kissing scenes, the Jacob/Bella kissing scenes and the final meadow scene; the love, romance, and chemistry in this movie was just perfect. It never felt overwhelming or underwhelming, but rather it had a perfect balance. The trio (Rob, Kristen, and Taylor) have amazing chemistry and it really came across onscreen where it counts.
I was fortunate enough to be able to see the film in both IMAX and the regular format. I’ve had a lot of people ask which is better, whether I recommend IMAX, etc., so here’s a little breakdown:
• Pros and Cons of IMAX? Better sound, more exciting in places (ie: the battle), Edward/Rob/Xavier/etc. at 3x the size of a regular screen…you get the idea. As far as cons, sometimes the film was a bit blurry in fast scenes and grainy in slower ones. And I love seeing the boys on a huge screen as much as the next person, but I couldn’t help but be distracted by the extreme close-ups where you could see every pore on their face.
• Which format is better? In my humble, headache-prone, un-tech savvy, Luddite (not really, but you get the point) opinion, I’m going to go with the regular format.
• Do I recommend it in IMAX? Absolutely, hands down. The film is only in IMAX for two weeks. If you’re a diehard fan like I think you are, you’ll want to experience the film in every format possible. Like I said, there are pros to the IMAX, so do yourself a favor and go see it in IMAX while you still can.
I’ll be the first to admit that I’m biased, but I give the film an easy ‘A’. Will the critics love it? Unless they’re a fan of the books or are within the target audience, I won’t hold my breath (Ebert, I’m lookin’ at you). There are things we are clued in on as fans that make sense to us, but may seem cheesy or out of place to someone who is not as informed on the material. I, personally, would prefer the film include these bits rather than exclude them, so as a diehard and very critical fan, I was pleased with all decisions made by the actors, the studio, Melissa Rosenberg, David Slade, etc. However, I will say that I think this movie will get much higher critic reviews than the previous two, simply based on the story line.
David Slade called The Twilight Saga: Eclipse “a love letter to the fans”, and it is just that. David, please consider this review my love letter to you